By: tlmoon2112
Id take Eli over Peyton anyday and twice on Sundays. Not because he’s better, but because he has a sense of humility that Peyton just flat out doesnt have.
View ArticleBy: notdemfalcons
Just chiming in on the “who has more talent around them argument” as well as the awesome suggestion that Archie put his DNA up for bid. Yes, Archie should! But also, you only need to look at his career...
View ArticleBy: lombardisshineinfoxborough
I couldn’t care less what the consensus is on Eli vs. Peyton or anybody else but I will say that Eli couldn’t possibly be any less representative of his fan base. Humble. Modest. Down to earth. It’s...
View ArticleBy: patriotera
Make it interesting. Ask him if he is the best Giants QB of all time Or better than Phil Simms.
View ArticleBy: skinsrock
Defense wins championships & Eli for most of his career has had the upper hand with the Giants… Like he said, not as good as Peyton, doesn’t have to be.
View ArticleBy: jedigiant
Defense wins championships but Eli had to lead two fourth quarter drives to win both of those championships! That’s something Payton couldn’t do. It ended up going the other way dealing the win for the...
View ArticleBy: mannyicey
Eli told the truth! Why? If Eli Manning were to get injured and had to sit out the entire season, would the Giants win a few games? I’m not talking about playoffs or anything. I’m talking about 1 or 2...
View ArticleBy: ggbblue
For these mental midgets who love to make the “Eli is only good because of his Defense” argument, I have just one logical question. Where was this vaunted Giants defense between 1990 and 2007? The time...
View ArticleBy: luckyarmpit
What more could you ask for as far as being humble and/or down-to-earth? Yes, I was a little harsh on Eli during his early years with the Giants but I couldn’t be happier to have him as QB of my...
View ArticleBy: bragerber
Oh yeah, because Eli put all the pressure on Brady and made it difficult for the Pats to score points in those SBs…oh wait, that was his defense!
View ArticleBy: pubobby2004
Super bowl = team award MVP = individual award Would anyone make the argument Trent dilfer was better than Marino? No. The one year the colts had a healthy legit defense they won it all. Peyton even...
View ArticleBy: joeyd524
Eli has 5-6 more good years ahead of him while Peyton’s career is pretty much over,so ask the question again in 2017..
View ArticleBy: Mr. Wright 212
lombardisshineinfoxborough says:Aug 14, 2012 9:14 AMI couldn’t care less what the consensus is on Eli vs. Peyton or anybody else but I will say that Eli couldn’t possibly be any less representative of...
View ArticleBy: lombardisshineinfoxborough
Mr. Wright 212 says: Aug 14, 2012 11:11 AM lombardisshineinfoxborough says:Aug 14, 2012 9:14 AMI couldn’t care less what the consensus is on Eli vs. Peyton or anybody else but I will say that Eli...
View ArticleBy: bigbluefan1
I am so tired of hearing all the BS out of Pats and Packer fans. When it comes to who is better the story is still being written When it comes to who beats the Packers and Pats when it counts well its...
View ArticleBy: jwreck
klownshoes says: Aug 14, 2012 2:46 AM Regardless, Eli’s had an ever-changing cast of WRs and TEs since he’s been in the league. He had Toomer for five years, but, clearly his skills were diminishing in...
View ArticleBy: patriotera
Eli has a career QB rating in the NFL of 82.1 Peyton = 94.9 Tom Brady = 96.4 Eli didn’t even get the Giants to the playoffs for back to back years. Then in a *lock out season, things work out for them.
View ArticleBy: defscottyb
Peyton Manning is a better quarterback than Eli Manning. Eli has just been luckier than Peyton. No offense to Eli, he is a very very good qb but not as good as Peyton.
View ArticleBy: defscottyb
Seriously, if you were staring your own NFL team and had to choose one of the two which one would you take (and throw out age). You would take Peyton hands down.
View ArticleBy: jjackwagon
“Indy never had a defense!” whine…whine…whine… “Eli is only good because of the defense!” cry…cry…cry… Look it’s not Eli’s fault that the Colts never put together a good enough defense to sustain...
View ArticleBy: crawfish2011
Seriously, Eli Manning is arguably better than Peyton. Eli Manning has the most road playoff wins ever. Eli Manning 5 -1 Dan Marino 1 – 6 Peyton Manning 2 – 5 Joe Montana 2-5 Brett Favre 3 – 7 Tom...
View ArticleBy: The Prophet
Funny I’ve never heard Peyton make the slightest implication that perhaps Eli might be “greater” since Eli is 2-0 in Super Bowls carried BY Eli, and Peyton is 1-1. I’d love to see some actual humility...
View ArticleBy: The Prophet
The real question is, you just entered the playoffs, who do you want to be QB for your team, Eli or Peyton. Before you answer think about their respective playoff histories. Not press voted awards,...
View ArticleBy: pongonfl
Well. Watching the packers-giants play off game last year I saw the dynamic that reminded me of the old AFC games between the Pats and Colts(going back to the mid 2000s here) Where the lack of pass...
View ArticleBy: bosspower
If I go by the Big time players make Big Plays in Big games……I have to go with Eli. “Make him throw to Pascoe, Make him throw to Manningham, this is a Cruz and Nicks game.” Peyton on the other hand...
View ArticleBy: richiebburg
If Peyton Manning had half a defense when the Colts had Him, Marvin Harrison, and Edgerrin James in their primes they would have won several superbowls.
View ArticleBy: n0hopeleft
I remember how much of a hater I was of other QBs, before Eli won my team 2 rings in 5 years. Now, when I read the hate, I just laugh at all of you – because I remember what it was like to SUCK. Go cry.
View ArticleBy: jasncondit
Truth – If Peyton Manning doesn’t come into the NFL and light it up, no way in the world does anyone draft Eli in the 1st round and let alone with the Giants. So the Giants need to thank Peyton in some...
View Article
